Skip to content

Baehr's Ice Cream Cottage

Ice cream shop and casual eats · Appleton, NY

Ice cream shop and casual eats in Appleton. Choose from hard ice cream, yogurt, custard, sundaes, shakes, and other frozen treats.

What they offer

  • Hard ice cream in 20 flavors
  • Yogurt and custard
  • Banana splits, sodas, floats, flurries, and specialty and kids' sundaes
  • In-season sundaes made with the cottage's own fresh fruit
  • Old-fashioned milkshakes made with real ice cream
  • Hot dogs, hamburgers, chili dogs, blue baconburgers, Italian sausage, French fries, and chicken sandwiches

About Baehr's Ice Cream Cottage

Baehr's Ice Cream Cottage serves ice cream, frozen treats, and casual food in a country setting. Its park-like seating area offers views of the sunsets.

What to do

  • Choose from hard ice cream, yogurt, custard, sundaes, shakes, and other frozen treats.
  • Enjoy a hot dog, burger, fries, or another savory option in the park-like seating area.

Season, hours and prices

Contact Baehr's Ice Cream Cottage for current hours, seasons and prices before traveling.

Tips for your visit

Try an in-season sundae made with the cottage's own fresh fruit.

Getting there

Nearby directory stops

Approximate straight-line distances; road routes may be longer.

Checked in November 2026 using the business website. Hours and seasons can change. How we check listings · Is this your business? Claim it free

Place details include data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL) and from the Overture Maps Foundation.

You may also like
‹ Trade Desk