About Rolling Pin Bakery
Rolling Pin Bakery is in the Three Village Shopping Plaza on Route 25A in East Setauket, across from St. James Church. Owner David Dombroff, a Culinary Institute of America graduate who learned the trade around his father's bagel shop, bought the former Glendale Bakery at 25 and has run it for about 30 years. In December 2025 the local weekly paper named him one of its People of the Year, noting that the day's leftover bread and pastries go to soup kitchens each night.
Cakes are the heart of the place. Sponge layers and fillings are made from scratch, and before the pandemic the shop turned out 45 to 55 wedding cakes on a typical weekend. The case holds carrot cake with cream cheese icing and walnuts, an Irish cream chocolate cake under ganache, a Silk and Satin cake layered with cheesecake and chocolate mousse, a raspberry-filled tri-color cake and a white chocolate mousse cake. Custom cakes come in vanilla, chocolate, marble, red velvet or carrot, with fillings that run from cannoli cream to banana custard and raspberry mousse.
Cupcakes, cookies, pastries and tarts fill out the counter, couples can request a wedding cake tasting through the bakery's website, and a kosher certification letter is posted there too. The shop is open seven days a week.
Hoshyla Farms in Manorville is about 30 minutes southeast by way of the Long Island Expressway, so a box of pastries from here travels well to a summer lavender day there.
What to do
- Pick up a tri-color or Silk and Satin cake from the case
- Request a wedding cake tasting
- Order a custom cake in red velvet or carrot with cannoli or mousse filling
- Grab cupcakes, cookies and tarts for the road
Season, hours and prices
- Season
- Open seven days a week
- Hours
- Open seven days a week; times not posted on their website (checked October 2026)
Tips for your visit
- From the Long Island Expressway, take exit 62 north on Nicolls Road to its end, turn right on Route 25A, and the bakery is about half a mile on the right
- Call ahead to confirm times, since daily hours aren't posted online
- Tell staff about any food allergies before ordering
Pair it with a lavender farm
Hoshyla Farms · about 30 minutes away
Hoshyla Farms in Manorville is about 30 minutes southeast on the Long Island Expressway; pick up pastries here on the way to its lavender.
Getting there
Questions
Does Rolling Pin Bakery make wedding cakes?
Yes. Wedding cakes and cupcakes are a specialty, and you can request a tasting.
Is it open on weekends?
Yes, the bakery is open seven days a week.
🗺️ Part of the guide Things to Do Near the Lavender Farms of Manorville & Riverhead, Long Island, New York
Checked in October 2026 against the business’s own website and local tourism pages. Hours and seasons change, so check with them before you go. How we check listings · Is this your business? Claim it free
